• About
    • The Magazine
    • The Foundation
    • The Collective
    • Columns
  • 2011 Calendar
  • The Dreams for Women Project
    • About
    • Postcards
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 1 – 4
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 5 – 8
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 9 – 12
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 13 -16
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 17 – 20
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 21 – 24
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 25 – 28
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 29 – 32
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 33 – 36
      • Dreams for Women Week 37 – 40
      • Dreams for Women Week 41 – 44
      • Dreams for Women Week 45 – 48
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 49 – 52
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 53 – 56
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 57– 60
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 61– 64
      • Dreams for Women Weeks 65– 68
  • Read Antigone Magazine 
  • Contact Us

Category Archives: Gardasil

Gardasil and the Right Wing Controversy…

20 Wednesday Jun 2007

Posted by antigonemagazine in Gardasil

≈ 1 Comment

Here’s an article from the Windsor Star about Gardasil, the vacine for young women that is meant to help prevent a number of strains of HPV, a sexually transmitted infection that leads to Cervical Cancer. Great thing right? One would think that a vaccine for cancer would be heralded as a breakthrough with people lining up from all over to ensure that they were innoculated… Well, not so much – at least not in the US where many religious conservatives see this vaccine as a message to their daughters (this vaccine is best given to girls aged 12-26 before they become sexually active) that it’s a free for all for sex.

I’m continually shocked and disturbed by how stupid people think young women are. I’m sure most young women know that there are other concerns when having sex and will continue to use condoms if they do so. I’m similarly shocked and disturbed by how religious conservatives think abstinence works and like to hold onto their scary statistics and diseases in order to scare teens from having sex – even at the expense of their health. But here’s my issue with this article: it talks mostly about a problem that isn’t really an issue here in Canada. There just isn’t the same resistance to the drug as there is in the US… so how does this article possibly encourage and create resistance to it that doesn’t already exist? The article focuses primarily on debunking ideas that Gardasil is a bad thing…

Although some are concerned that giving girls the vaccine may lead them to believe they can safely have sex, medical officials say the benefits far outweigh any such concern.

“There’s a kind of hysteria about the drug especially within the religious right in the United States, but for me it’s a public health issue,” said Samantha Brennan, head of philosophy at the University of Western Ontario.

Cervical cancer is a leading cause of death in young woman, and in most cases results from exposure to HPV. Gardasil is most effective when given to girls and young women before they have sexual activity, but studies are being done on its efficacy in older women who have had sex and have even been exposed to the virus which in most cases clears up on its own instead of leading to cancer. The vaccine also guards against genital warts caused by HPV. It is not recommended for boys or men, pregnant women or girls under nine years.

Officials agree that even if a person has an HPV infection, getting the vaccine can still be protective because Gardasil works against the two strains that cause cancer, and two that cause genital warts.

“When you put a helmet on your kid to ride a bicycle, you’re protecting them,” Murphy said. “We know that abstinence does not work.”

Local health officials are firmly on side when it comes to innoculating girls. “If I had a teenage daughter, I would definitely provide the vaccine,” said Dr. Allen Heimann of the Windsor-Essex County Health Unit which provides Gardasil in its clinic.

“No woman in Canada should die of cervical cancer,” he said, adding that all women still should be screened for the disease on a regular basis. The vaccine is not yet covered by provincial health plans, and the three necessary injections – given over six months – can cost up to $400. The federal government has set aside $300 million for provinces to fund the vaccine, but the national protocols have not been established, a spokesman for the Ontario health ministry said.

“To my mind there isn’t a moral argument,” said Guy Grenier, a London, Ont. psychologist and author. “We should be educating our kids about sex.”

Stephanie Driedger, a nurse practitioner at Windsor’s Teen Health Centre, said the vaccine is offered to every eligible client who comes in for a physical.

“We have noticed an increase in interest,” Driedger said. Most of the recipients are between 16 and 25 and many of them are sexually active, she said, but she said most of them do not view the vaccine as a carte blanche to have sex.

“I don’t think that’s the impression they’re under. It’s the word, cancer. The benefits outweigh the risks,” Driedger said.

“It’s just a new thing for me,” said Cathy, a Windsor-area resident with two daughters aged 19 and 13. “I have thought about it. I’m not 100 per cent informed.

“It’s been sitting on the back burner. I’d like to open it and discuss it with them,” she said, adding that although Garadasil may be effective, she still leans towards encouraging her daughters to be careful about having sex.

So… the article isn’t THAT bad… although it doesn’t mention the other vaccine that will be coming out for cervical cancer in the next few months. Nor does it talk about another debate that is currently going on – which is whether to also innoculate young boys, in order to save them from penis cancer (admittedly rare) and help create herd immunity, by preventing them from spreading HPV to their partners. If I had a son I would immunize him against HPV!!! Also, what man would want to be a carrier for a disease that might cause cancer in the people that he loves? Thoughts?

Gardasil and the Right Wing Controversy…

20 Wednesday Jun 2007

Posted by Amanda in Gardasil

≈ 1 Comment

Here’s an article from the Windsor Star about Gardasil, the vacine for young women that is meant to help prevent a number of strains of HPV, a sexually transmitted infection that leads to Cervical Cancer. Great thing right? One would think that a vaccine for cancer would be heralded as a breakthrough with people lining up from all over to ensure that they were innoculated… Well, not so much – at least not in the US where many religious conservatives see this vaccine as a message to their daughters (this vaccine is best given to girls aged 12-26 before they become sexually active) that it’s a free for all for sex.

I’m continually shocked and disturbed by how stupid people think young women are. I’m sure most young women know that there are other concerns when having sex and will continue to use condoms if they do so. I’m similarly shocked and disturbed by how religious conservatives think abstinence works and like to hold onto their scary statistics and diseases in order to scare teens from having sex – even at the expense of their health. But here’s my issue with this article: it talks mostly about a problem that isn’t really an issue here in Canada. There just isn’t the same resistance to the drug as there is in the US… so how does this article possibly encourage and create resistance to it that doesn’t already exist? The article focuses primarily on debunking ideas that Gardasil is a bad thing…

Although some are concerned that giving girls the vaccine may lead them to believe they can safely have sex, medical officials say the benefits far outweigh any such concern.

“There’s a kind of hysteria about the drug especially within the religious right in the United States, but for me it’s a public health issue,” said Samantha Brennan, head of philosophy at the University of Western Ontario.

Cervical cancer is a leading cause of death in young woman, and in most cases results from exposure to HPV. Gardasil is most effective when given to girls and young women before they have sexual activity, but studies are being done on its efficacy in older women who have had sex and have even been exposed to the virus which in most cases clears up on its own instead of leading to cancer. The vaccine also guards against genital warts caused by HPV. It is not recommended for boys or men, pregnant women or girls under nine years.

Officials agree that even if a person has an HPV infection, getting the vaccine can still be protective because Gardasil works against the two strains that cause cancer, and two that cause genital warts.

“When you put a helmet on your kid to ride a bicycle, you’re protecting them,” Murphy said. “We know that abstinence does not work.”

Local health officials are firmly on side when it comes to innoculating girls. “If I had a teenage daughter, I would definitely provide the vaccine,” said Dr. Allen Heimann of the Windsor-Essex County Health Unit which provides Gardasil in its clinic.

“No woman in Canada should die of cervical cancer,” he said, adding that all women still should be screened for the disease on a regular basis. The vaccine is not yet covered by provincial health plans, and the three necessary injections – given over six months – can cost up to $400. The federal government has set aside $300 million for provinces to fund the vaccine, but the national protocols have not been established, a spokesman for the Ontario health ministry said.

“To my mind there isn’t a moral argument,” said Guy Grenier, a London, Ont. psychologist and author. “We should be educating our kids about sex.”

Stephanie Driedger, a nurse practitioner at Windsor’s Teen Health Centre, said the vaccine is offered to every eligible client who comes in for a physical.

“We have noticed an increase in interest,” Driedger said. Most of the recipients are between 16 and 25 and many of them are sexually active, she said, but she said most of them do not view the vaccine as a carte blanche to have sex.

“I don’t think that’s the impression they’re under. It’s the word, cancer. The benefits outweigh the risks,” Driedger said.

“It’s just a new thing for me,” said Cathy, a Windsor-area resident with two daughters aged 19 and 13. “I have thought about it. I’m not 100 per cent informed.

“It’s been sitting on the back burner. I’d like to open it and discuss it with them,” she said, adding that although Garadasil may be effective, she still leans towards encouraging her daughters to be careful about having sex.

So… the article isn’t THAT bad… although it doesn’t mention the other vaccine that will be coming out for cervical cancer in the next few months. Nor does it talk about another debate that is currently going on – which is whether to also innoculate young boys, in order to save them from penis cancer (admittedly rare) and help create herd immunity, by preventing them from spreading HPV to their partners. If I had a son I would immunize him against HPV!!! Also, what man would want to be a carrier for a disease that might cause cancer in the people that he loves? Thoughts?

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)

Archives

  • September 2011
  • July 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • June 2009
  • May 2009
  • April 2009
  • March 2009
  • February 2009
  • January 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • December 2007
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007
  • April 2007
  • March 2007

Categories

  • 2010
  • Abortion
  • american politics
  • Antigone Foundation
  • Antigone Magazine
  • Beauty
  • BlogHer
  • CEDAW
  • Charter
  • child care
  • Commission on the Status of Women
  • CONNECT
  • Darfur
  • Day of rememberance
  • Dec 6
  • Diary of an Activist
  • Dreams for women
  • Elizabeth May
  • Environment
  • Equal Voice
  • Federal Election
  • female politicians
  • feminist freethinker
  • feministing
  • Feminists Who Totally Rock
  • film
  • France
  • Gardasil
  • Gay Rights
  • Gloria Steinem
  • Hillary Clinton
  • Human rights
  • human trafficking
  • I'm a feminist because
  • immigrant women
  • In need of enlightenment
  • Legalized prostitution
  • LGBT
  • marriage
  • Masculinity
  • Media
  • Minerva
  • Mira Hall
  • Morgentaler
  • motherhood
  • NDP
  • Ottawa
  • Oxfam
  • patriarchy
  • pay equity
  • pensions
  • persons case
  • poverty
  • Pro-choice
  • Queer Issues
  • Race
  • Rape
  • Reproductive Rights
  • Retirement
  • robert pickton
  • sexism
  • Sexual Assault
  • Sexual paradox
  • sexuality
  • Single Women
  • Some Leaders are Born Women
  • Spivak
  • status of women
  • stereotypes
  • Stupid misogynists
  • The Feminist Scholar
  • UBC
  • UN
  • UNIFEM
  • US elections
  • vancouver events
  • Vancouver Sun
  • Violence against women
  • Women and politics
  • women in politics
  • Women in the Middle east
  • women leaders
  • Women's groups
  • women's issues
  • Young women
  • Your Voice

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • antigonemagazine.wordpress.com
    • Join 27 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • antigonemagazine.wordpress.com
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar